Murder Mystery Dinner Shows

February 22, 2024 @ 7:00PM — February 25, 2024 @ 10:00PM Eastern Time (US & Canada) Add to Calendar

St. George Theatre: 35 Hyatt St Staten Island, NY 10301 Get Directions

Murder Mystery Dinner Shows image

Murder Mystery Dinner Shows - February 2024

Upon purchase, please email seating arrangements and requests to

Join us for an extremely unique and exclusive opportunity to visit the theatre like no one else has before! Your scandalous experience takes place on the St, George Theatre stage with table seating facing the majestic, newly restored interior of the venue! Seating is limited.

I Love the 80's to Death - Friday, February 23, 2024

It’s the 80’s again, and all of the big names are here for a big concert. Tensions run rampant as backstage secrets spill out into the spotlight with like, totally tragic results! This isn’t an episode of Miami Vice! This is like…murder. It’s up to you to bust it like a ghost, for sure! Peg your jeans, slouch your socks, flash some neon, put on way too much eyeliner and get that hair up! You are going to solve this crime in style. No time to be Too Shy! You are a Smooth Operator, and you know to listen to those Careless Whispers. It’s time to put on your Sunglasses at Night and Relax. Time after time…You will solve the case.

Midnight at the Masquerade - Saturday, February 24, 2024

Attend the Billionaires’ Club Annual Masquerade Ball and help get this soiree back on track by trading clues with your guests, gathering information, and solving the crime before the masked menace gets away! Evening wear, ball gowns, Venetian masks, suits, and tuxes are what to wear to this high class night of masks and murder. Get ready for a glamorous evening of mystery, intrigue, and murder at this masquerade ball murder mystery party!

Now You See It; Now You Don't - Sunday, February 25, 2024

The crowd was hushed as the museum proprietor got ready to unveil the prized display of the evening, the Stomach of the Ocean Diamond, only to find it had been stolen while the crowd mingled in ignorant bliss. Now it is up to you, your guests, and the detective to find the thief and restore the diamond to its rightful place to get the unveiling back on track! Who is the carat caper, and who will solve the crime to make this night of mystery the night of beauty it was intended to be? Dress in your fanciest evening gowns and suits. This is a museum unveiling, after all, and only the finest will do. Tonight will be an evening of high fashion and suspenseful mystery, with one thrilling conclusion.